| Home | www.OLQE.com | Course Calendar | FAQ | Links | Register Online |

Today is 29 Nov 2022

Legal CPD Courses
CPT Courses
Risk Management Course
OLQE 2022
OLQE 2021
OLQE 2020
OLQE 2019
OLQE 2018
OLQE 2017
OLQE 2016
OLQE 2015
OLQE 2014
OLQE 2013
OLQE 2012
OLQE 2011
OLQE 2010
OLQE 2009
OLQE 2008
OLQE 2007
Course Categories
Discount Packages
Contact us
Y Charity Events Y

What our delegates said Join Our Mailing List Suggestions for New Courses Speaker for LexOmnibus

Course Details Course List | Course Calendar

(Webinar via ZOOM) Illegality, Equity and Trusts in Hong Kong: clean hands, ex turpi causa, reliance, locus poenitentiae, range of factors or what?
Steven Gallagher, Professor of Practice in Law, Associate Dean (Academic & Student Affairs), The Faculty of Law, The Chinese University of Hong Kong
Date: 15 March 2023 (Wednesday)
Time: 2:30pm - 5:45pm
Level: I (Intermediate)
For delegates who have prior knowledge of the subject area
Language: English
Fee: HK$ 1,800
Accreditation: (3 CPD Points will be applied for)
Ref: L23TP01
Venue: Webinar Course
Presenter's Biography:

Steven Gallagher was awarded a first class LL.B. He was called to the Bar of England and Wales in 2006. Steven teaches the equity and trusts courses for undergraduate and postgraduate students. Steven also teaches a course on art, antiquities, cultural heritage and the law on the LLM programme. Steven has presented continuing professional development courses for solicitors in Hong Kong on many topics associated with property. Steven's research interests include equity and the law of trusts, cultural heritage law and legal history. He is not a technologist.

In 2016, the majority of the UK Supreme Court, in Patel v Mirza [2016] UKSC 42, adopted a new test to decide if a plaintiff's case should be barred for illegality - the Range of Factors Test. This test has been applied by the court in Hong Kong and also rejected in light of Hong Kong's own Court of Appeal guidance that our courts should follow the Reliance Principle developed by the House of Lord in Tinsley v Milligan [1994] 1 AC 340. This seminar will consider the development of the doctrine of illegality from its roots in the equitable maxim He who comes to equity must come with clean hands, and the common law maxim Ex turpi causa non oritur action. The seminar will consider the original approach of equity and the common law to plaintiffs who founded their actions on illegal acts in the seminal judgments of Lord Mansfield in Holman v Johnson (1775) 1 Cowp 341, bringing his equity to the law, and the more formalistic approach of Lord Eldon in Muckleston v Brown (1801) 6 Ves 52, arguably bringing law into equity when he opined, "Let the estate lie where it falls". The seminar then considers the developments in the doctrine in law and equity through the influential comments of Lord Denning in Tinker v Tinker [1970] 1 All ER 540, to the development of the modern approach to claims of illegality. This modern approach consists of three main trends in equity's relaxation of the harshness of the common law: The Reliance Principle, the doctrine of locus poenitentiae, and the common sense interpretation of law to categorise the maligned acts as outside any illegality identified at law and especially in statute. The seminar will also consider the use of the doctrine by defendants attempting to hide behind the attribution of their illegal acts to their principals. The seminar will conclude by considering the application of the Range of Factors test in the UK and its possible application in Hong Kong. In particular, the seminar will consider whether Hong Kong should continue to apply the Reliance Principle and its associated exceptions, adopt the Range of Factors Test, follow the guidance of other common law jurisdictions (e.g. Nelson v Nelson (1995) 184 CLR 538) or perhaps go its own way.

  • The traditional approach of equity to issues of illegality in Gascoigne v Gascoigne [1918] 1 KB 223 and Tinker v Tinker [1970] 1 All ER 540;

  • The supposed relaxation of the doctrine of illegality in the Reliance Principle as applied in Tinsley v Milligan [1994] 1 AC 340;

  • The doctrine of Locus poenitentiae: Tribe v. Tribe [1996] Ch 107;

  • There is no "true" illegality or the legislative prohibition is for "other mischief" Ali v Khan [2002] EWCA Civ 974;

  • Common sense approaches in Hong Kong to trusts in Home Ownership Scheme flats - Cheuk Shu Yin v Yip So Wan and Lo King Fai [2012] HKEC 1554;

  • The Range of Factors Test as adopted by the UK Supreme Court in Patel v Mirza [2016] UKSC 42;

  • Application of the Test by the Supreme Court in Singularis Holdings Limited (in liquidation) v Daiwa Capital Markets Europe Limited [2019] UKSC 50 and Stoffel & Co v Grondona [2020] UKSC 42;

  • The application of the Test in professional negligence claims against solicitors by the UK Court of Appeal in Day v Womble Bond Dickinson [2020] EWCA Civ 447;

  • The application of the Test in Hong Kong: Chung Tin Pui v Li Pak Sau [2017] HKEC 2103;

  • The restriction of the Range of Factors Test in Hong Kong: Arrow ECS Norway AS v M Yang Trading Ltd [2018] HKCFI 975.

Category: Trust, Succession & Probate
Course Booking Terms & Conditions

Download Registration Form


Register Online
Download Registration Form
Upcoming Courses
29 November 2022 (Tue)
2:30pm - 5:45pm
(Webinar via Zoom) Regulatory Update - Insider Dealing
30 November 2022 (Wed)
2:30pm - 5:45pm
(Webinar via ZOOM) Recent Developments in Company Law
9 December 2022 (Fri)
2:30pm - 5:45pm
(Webinar via ZOOM) Introduction of Cybercrime in Hong Kong
13 December 2022 (Tue)
2:30pm - 5:45pm
(Webinar via Zoom) Professional Liability
14 December 2022 (Wed)
2:30pm - 5:45pm
(Webinar via ZOOM) When is a trust not a trust?
15 December 2022 (Thu)
2:30pm - 5:45pm
(Webinar via Zoom) The Social and Economic Values of Hong Kong Notarial Services
16 December 2022 (Fri)
2:30pm - 5:45pm
(Webinar via ZOOM) Administrators, Executors and Beneficiaries of an Estate: Powers, Responsibilities and Topical Issues
11 January 2023 (Wed)
2:30pm - 5:45pm
(Webinar via ZOOM) Adverse Possession: Squatter's Rights and Encroaching on Other's Land in Hong Kong
16 January 2023 (Mon)
2:30pm - 5:45pm
(Webinar via Zoom) Connected Transaction
17 January 2023 (Tue)
2:30pm - 5:45pm
(Webinar via Zoom) Oaths, Affidavits and Declarations: Local and Foreign Issues
18 January 2023 (Wed)
2:30pm - 5:45pm
(Webinar via Zoom) [RME elective] Cybersecurity and the Law Firm
19 January 2023 (Thu)
2:30pm - 5:45pm
(Webinar via Zoom) Practical aspects of SFC Investigation

Home | About Us | Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy | Personal Information Collection Statement | Contact Us  
Copyright © 2007 - 2022 Lex Omnibus Limited. All rights reserved.